The ISSB: A Game-Changer for ESG Reporting
Editors' note: This post was updated to include the ISSB launching a consultation on its first two proposed standards.
The announcement of the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) at COP26 in November 2021 didn’t just create ripples: for those involved or interested in environmental, social, and governance (ESG) reporting, the news was a tidal wave. The impact that ISSB will have, and the shift that it represents, cannot be understated. This announcement was big, but in such ESG-driven times, maybe we shouldn’t have been too surprised.
Developing globally accepted sustainability reporting standards is in and of itself big news—but we knew that it was coming. What was less clear before COP26 were the plans to consolidate the Value Reporting Foundation (an organization recently formed through the merger of the SASB and International Integrated Reporting Council) and the Climate Disclosure Standards Board (CDSB) to form the ISSB. There have been calls to consolidate the diverse ESG standards landscape for years. The fact that it’s actually happening is truly remarkable, and it’s fantastic news for businesses, investors, and society as a whole.
The International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) has launched a consultation on its first two proposed standards:
- Exposure Draft IFRS S1 General Requirements for Disclosure of Sustainability-related Financial Information
- Exposure Draft IFRS S2 Climate-related Disclosures
The proposals build upon the recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) and incorporate industry-based disclosure requirements from the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) standards. The ISSB was seeking feedback until the end of July 2022 and aims to review the feedback and issue new standards by the end of the year.
Additionally, the ISSB has requested comments before September 30, 2022, to aid with the development of the International Financial Reporting Standards’ (IFRS) Sustainability Reporting Taxonomy. Its aim is to consider the “digital consumption of sustainability disclosures from the outset.”
Global standards, universal simplicity
While the ISSB won’t be a panacea for all complexity attached to ESG reporting—the scale of the task will be just as big as it has always been—it will provide consistent standards for organizations across the world, significantly reduce cross-framework mapping, and simplify the related painful elements of the reporting process. The Technical Readiness Working Group (TRWG) shared the first prototype disclosure requirements and the schedule of work, which was set up by the IFRS Foundation. Six more deliverables from this group are already slated for handover to the ISSB, so expect more detail to emerge over the coming months.
Knowing that the ISSB won’t start from scratch is more welcome relief for businesses. Along with the substantial body of work brought in via the consolidation, SASB standards, Integrated Reporting Framework, and the CDSB Framework, they will build on the work conducted by other leaders in the sustainability regulation field, such as the standards developed by the TCFD. The TCFD forms part of the TRWG, and its recommendations formed the foundations of the TRWG’s initial climate prototype.
The notable omission of the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) from this group doesn’t need to cause alarm. After the announcement of the ISSB formation, GRI shared the following statement: "GRI stands ready to engage with the IFRS Foundation in support of this aim. We look forward to hearing more about the remit and scope of their new ventures, as well as inputting to the development of the proposed climate standard.” We are at the beginning of what is going to be an exciting and incredibly beneficial journey. As time progresses, we will learn more about their plans.
In time, we will also have a firm picture of which countries are going to adopt the standard. A statement published by the UK government names the 38 jurisdictions across six continents that have signed a letter welcoming the announcement—among them Brazil, China, the European Commission, and the United States.
Ultimately, all of this collaboration and consolidation means that businesses will no longer need to fumble in the dark to navigate a labyrinth of existing measurement frameworks, guidance, protocols, rankings, indices, and standards. They can clearly see the path ahead of them and have reassurance that they can move beyond their current situation.
The ISSB will bring transparency and trust to ESG reports
As it currently stands, the sheer volume of voluntary guidance around ESG disclosures is overwhelming, complex, and confusing. Despite having the best intentions, the guidance that’s currently in place is making ESG reporting more opaque for businesses, investors, and stakeholders alike. With one single set of global norms, it’s possible to achieve clarity. And, however heavy this particular crown may be, having finance teams play a critical role in the reporting process will mean it’s possible to deliver transparent ESG reports that investors can trust.
Transparency shouldn’t be elusive. Investors need to have access to information that enables them to clearly compare one company’s sustainability performance against another. They need to clearly understand how a company’s performance relates to its value creation. Without this knowledge, it’s almost impossible to make fully informed business and investment decisions that align with globally accepted climate goals.
However, a consistent set of standards is not the only key to trust. Financial information also usually has stronger control requirements, assurance requirements, and clear lines of sign-off and responsibilities. Regional laws and regulations will have a strong role to play here as well.
The ISSB will relieve significant pain for businesses
The ISSB isn’t a wholesale reinvention of the entire ESG reporting process. It also isn’t going to replace the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and the associated EU standards that businesses across Europe are preparing for—it will complement them. And the European Commission has stated that, “The proposed EU sustainability reporting standards would build on and contribute to standardization initiatives at global level.“ Although it won’t make a major dent in the immense amount of data and compilation work that goes into creating an ESG report, it’s not going to add any additional pain to an already complex process.
The simplicity that it promises and the reassurance that it provides will spur businesses to do the work to create ESG reports that meet investor expectations. The reality is that it will take time for businesses to transform their end-to-end ESG reporting processes. Many are already doing the work in anticipation of the CSRD being mandated. Their priority now will be to ensure that transitions are easy and smooth. To achieve this, they need to reassess their current set-ups and not be too fixed on using the existing solutions that they have hard coded in place.
Forbes called the creation of the ISSB, “the biggest change in corporate reporting since the 1930s.” Others have referred to it as a “tectonic shift.” And it’s not clickbait. It’s not hyperbole. It’s true. Businesses, and their reporting teams in particular, will rightly be celebrating this announcement. They’ve been suffering significant pain.
The IFRS has made sure that the ISSB will make a real impact: it’s the standard board that offers real, strong pain relief. And sure, businesses know they have a lot of work ahead of them. But, in the long run, the siren sounded from COP26 that change is imminent, that global standards are coming and that ESG reporting standards are going to be consolidated and made consistent across the globe. That’s as good a reason as any to feel a sense of relief.